Will PR replace Advertising?
Some say P.R. will overtake advertising in the new digital world. I wouldn’t bet on it. But, new projects from Ben & Jerry’s and Pull-Ups, of all companies, offer a tantalizing glimpse into where the p.r. industry is headed.
This weekend, I was watching C-Span (yes, my weekends are THAT exciting), listening to social media guru Jeff Jarvis of buzzmachine.com talk with the Communications Director of Google about the future of new media. During his talk, he said that previously, p.r. filled in the holes in a marketing plan that weren’t addressed by advertising. In the new world, it is advertising that will fill in the holes p.r. can’t address.
I’ll lace together two threads from his conversation to illustrate this point…First, he hypothesized about how great it would be if American automakers became completely interactive with their customers. He outlined a website that would allow customers to completely customize their cars…adding in i-pod dockers, picking out the type of seat, choosing engine upgrades, special colors, until the entire car was completely customized to you. He also recommended making consumers complete partners in the product development process for new models, which are currently veiled in secrecy. His second point: In a world such as this, the company is so interactive with its consumers, sharing a complete 360 degree model p.r. relationship, that the need for advertising is lessened. Advertising is used only to create awareness that can’t be achieved online…to introduce something new, to create a new buzz.
I think his statement is a little strong. Did DVDs kill the movie industry? No, but it forced the movie industry to make their movies into destination viewing. I think the move into new media will be a lot like that. Now is a great time to be in p.r., because we are uniquely positioned to help our clients create these new relationships online. It will take our industry to places we never even dreamed possible. While I do believe advertising will continue to be important, it will be used more judiciously, and not for every single message a company needs to get out. The revolution is well underway.
Here’s a couple of companies that are taking consumer interactivity seriously, and reaping huge benefits:
Pullups Potty Project
Nobody wants to talk about poo. But if you’ve ever had a potty training toddler, let’s face it, you’re knee deep in it. You’ll spend endless hours talking with other parents about how to get your kids out of this developmental quagmire. It’s a moment in time when you will do darn near anything to be successful. Thankfully, the folks from pullups are there to help. Not only do they have a rockin’ website where you can read all kinds of blogs and get very helpful coupons, but they’ve just launched the “potty project” . They identifed several different potty training “styles” that children have, and have hired families who represent that style. They are doing video diaries, blogging about their experiences, and answering other questions from parents. As someone who had to try about 40 different strategies before I found one that worked with my kids, talking to parents of a kid acting just like yours would help a lot. It’s really hit a chord with parents…to the tune of 2 million unique visits so far. Considering that there are only 8 million parents in the US who are potty training their kids at any one time, that is an absolutely staggering response. And just think about the mortification potential for embarrassing these potty project stars in a few years, when they bring home their first date.
Ben & Jerry’s “Do the World a Flavor”
Ben & Jerry’s is having a contest asking fans to combine ingredients on their website, creating their own flavor, which they can name. If they win, the winning flavor will be sold internationally, and also in Ben & Jerry’s by the scoop stores. I think this is a brilliant idea. But their prizes need a little help. Runners up get coupons (weeeee!), and the grand prize winner gets a trip for ONE to a chocolate farm in the Dominican Republic (somebody…call Samantha Brown!) And just think of the bragging rights you will get when your flavor idea and name is sold, and Ben & Jerry’s makes all that money off it. Guys, could you not at least let the winner pick a charity of their choice that would get some benefit? Still, you’ve got to give Ben & Jerry’s a big shout out for being one of the most innovative food companies out there. Check it out at Do the World a Flavor.



May 23rd, 2009 at 3:42 pm
[...] * Will PR replace advertising? [...]
June 3rd, 2009 at 8:30 pm
There’s absolutely no reason not to use coupons. I’ve become very fond of them, especially lately with prices in the grocery skyrocketing. Why wouldn’t you use coupons, its like free money!
August 30th, 2009 at 4:12 pm
I liked reading your blog…keep up the good work.
September 10th, 2009 at 9:44 am
Very interesting to read it
March 1st, 2010 at 4:10 pm
Hi! Your post rocks and is a really nice read!
March 13th, 2010 at 11:24 pm
Hi great blog yea nice work our review website will soon be adding reviews on blogs and add them to our websites as the top best 10 websites to visit we also do reviews on Product Reviews all types of reviews
March 16th, 2010 at 12:20 pm
thanks for posting this
March 21st, 2010 at 4:34 am
Not a bad post in any respect, would just have liked some more details and some of the things explained a little more.
March 21st, 2010 at 12:29 pm
nice post. I totally agree with you.
April 5th, 2010 at 1:40 am
I just wanted to let you know that I learned a lot from your post and I really enjoyed reading it. I was doing some research on google and I’m happy I discovered your blog. Again, thanks for the info.
May 22nd, 2010 at 9:11 am
I think PR will never replace advertising… this will never happend!
May 27th, 2010 at 7:36 pm
I do see PR as a very important part of any marketing campaign. And yes I can see it benefiting companies if they hire out the work to companies that are already in the field.
It makes perfect sense to hire people that are good at what they do and stick to what you do best. So if you sell shoes then obviously you should be hiring a PR company to do it for ya.
Good writeup too.
June 13th, 2010 at 11:40 pm
A Fantastic write up, I will be sure to bookmark this in my Clipmarks account. Have a great day.
June 20th, 2010 at 8:58 pm
I’ve tried to comment several times on this post, but in order the website freezes in some manner every time I push the submit button. A pitty really, because this is a kind of post that deserves to be commented.
June 30th, 2010 at 5:36 am
Everything has improved extremely grateful to you for the sper working in the whole program ..
June 30th, 2010 at 10:11 am
I feel a lot more men and women will need to read this, really excellent info.
July 2nd, 2010 at 2:38 pm
I have been searching for more information on these kinds of coupons for a long time now.